Post by BlockExtreme

Y 1w
1Gwece…AV6R Unverified · twetch

Insurance is the secondary avenue. When the thieves can't be found and the property not recovered.

Let's state it again:

The mechanism described above works for EVERYTHING in the world.

Why not for Bitcoin, which has the additional advantage of flagging stolen coins, making theft useless?

It's a simple question.
Convince me with an actual answer.

136zYT…BNgK Unverified · twetch

I've already told you. Insurance is unrelated with property rights. If you have to have it then it's not a right but a duty.

You didn't describe the mechanism. The mechanism is to return the property to the rightful owner. Not subscribe insurances.

Flagging stolen coins has zero effect. This is not ETH. You can mix UTXOs and coins remain active. You need to block the coins. DAR does this.

What the chain says
Block
Unconfirmed (mempool)
Time
2026-11-11T15:37:17Z
Signer
136zYTEHSK2xs4gUrpzTPovJA2VCo7BNgK
App
twetch
Type
reply
Content type
text/markdown

Fields the transaction did not carry are omitted. Open the payload to see the bytes as stored.

Signed by 136zYTEHSK2xs4gUrpzTPovJA2VCo7BNgK Unverified

Replies (11)

Y 1w
1Gwece…AV6R Unverified · twetch
Replying to@136zYT…BNgK

Seems like our disagreement is this:

You think Bitcoin needs special mechanisms to deal with theft and it needs it so desperately that it's worth it to introduce a new mechanism that can and will be abused especially in a world where the fact that criminals are in power is increasingly hard to deny

I don't.

I think the common mechanism are enough and introducing something that turns Bitcoin into a bootlicking joke is unnecessary and dangerous.

136zYT…BNgK Unverified · twetch
Replying to@1Gwece…AV6R

DAR is not part of Bitcoin. Bitcoin rules don't include DAR. Neither there's any Bitcoin process that includes DAR. DAR is a law action. Look at it as a transaction done by the court.

What we disagree:

I accept courts fail. Sometimes decisions are not fair. Or rightful. Corruption exists. But courts are infinitely better than not having them. That would be accepting all stolen property as rightful instead of accepting correct return of property with less damage from court failure.

What you don't understand is that you cannot return Bitcoin to the rightful owner without DAR. Reasons given several times.

Y 1w
1Gwece…AV6R Unverified · twetch
Replying to@136zYT…BNgK

By mechanism I was referring to whatever manner in which coins are moved, confiscated or resigned that isn't in the WP.

Thought that was clear.

Courts or no courts is a false dichotomy that has nothing to do with what we are discussing.

If stolen Bitcoin cannot be recovered I wonder what all the recovery firms do for a living.

One last thing: what about lost coins? Do they also need a special mechanism or do you agree with Satoshi that they simply make everyone else's coins more valuable?

136zYT…BNgK Unverified · twetch
Replying to@1Gwece…AV6R

That mechanism is the same on the examples i gave for physical property and others. The same way a stock barer holder or a bicycle have different law enforcements for different property.

Only coins that have access can be recovered. All these hacks aren't being recovered. Or haven't you noticed?!

Concerning lost coins why don't you look at Noah Doe lawsuit. Coin recovery best case to look at.

Again property rights are independent of Bitcoin. Courts decide. It is the mechanism agreed by society. If someone wins lost coins in court then it is valid. Again check Noah Doe's lawsuit.

Continue thread →

This thread is longer than one page shows. Open a reply to see what follows it.