Paper wallet meaning, writting down phrase and hiding it away somewhere?
Post by shruggr
BRC100 wallets will be around in 2030, but cold storage without cold UTXO storage, may not work reliably on any wallet. You must presume that somebody will continue to find it worth-while to keep a multi-terabyte index to lookup UTXOs by address, when address re-use (and even use at all) may become a diminishing reality. I'm sure someone will for several years, but maybe not 20 years in the future.
What the chain says
- Block
- 959 594
- Time
- 2026-07-26T21:41:03Z
- Signer
- 14aqJ2hMtENYJVCJaekcrqi12fiZJzoWGK
- App
- treechat
- Type
- reply
- Content type
- text/markdown
- Name in tx
- shruggr
Fields the transaction did not carry are omitted. Open the payload to see the bytes as stored.
14aqJ2hMtENYJVCJaekcrqi12fiZJzoWGK Verified CustodialReplies (44)
Obsolescence of supposed sound money within a couple of decades is not exactly a feature, a person can dig up gold from any culture from the past several millennia and nobody's gonna argue about its UTXO
I mean I don't think anybody's gonna argue that I'm pro real bitcoin, but this endless debate over wallets and upgrades, I remember that the Genesis upgrade was possibly going to be the death of legacy addresses and paper wallets if you didn't make them ahead of the upgrade happening, it's all just exhausting and even big business enterprise no matter how many zero confirmation and dust transactions are afforded them, if they have to keep playing this hopscotch game of what works and what doesn't like it will never get adopted.
And if I sound like a wet blanket, I don't think people are quite grasping where this critique is coming from. I've hung out since 2018 and I have stayed in the trenches the entire time my disposition hasn't changed about the money or the fundamentals, but everybody and their brother deciding that they've got the new latest optimized can't yet be defeated software idea shall go back into the frying pan as King Crimson put it
Evocative of many things... over many years..
What? All I'm saying is you are not self-sovereign if you don't keep yours UTXOs. You MUST rely on somebody else to maintain an index for you to find them and to give them to you. This has always been the case for all cold wallets on every fork.
Ain't no dummy. Have my UTXOs. More speaking to the fud-E-dudeez clambering about every so often as to what hypothetically won't work & what actually becomes the case, david, but i get it. Mayhaps i will be cool enough for more than passing condescension some day 🤷♂️ 💀😘 we luddites who appreciate the BitCoin ethos just want to participate in the BitCoin ecosystem without a fud match every 2-3 years if possible. If, i have misread the feigned question prologue, then kindly forgive me, if not then kindly ... shrug it off from another nonbrocoder what with time so valuable & candor like chewing broken glass. Almost enjoyable
You are an enigma to understand the tone in your posting. I'm sorry if you heard mine as passing condescension. No belittlement was intended. I can't tall if you are angry or light hearted or offended, or a troll. :D
You read the same way. 🤝
Probably a BitCoin thing.
I'm usually pretty straightforward unless I feel like I'm being fucked with. You are no intellectual slouch, to put it mildly, for what that's worth. I was misreading. My personal life is coloring my perceptions at the moment—honest vivisection—the real bitcoin in-fighting on other platforms is doing no one in the culture any good at the moment even though there are a lot of good people bickering. I will try to do better
& please forgive the overfamiliarity in my initial comment. Sometimes the multiple entendres are quite irresistible, and probably a bit out of line. Those are costly signals, but also measures of respect. I will let you know exactly hiding who you are, but that doesn't mean a person should just say things because they are clever. Please accept my sincere apology
& please forgive the overfamiliarity in my initial comment. Sometimes the multiple entendres are quite irresistible, and probably a bit out of line. Those are costly signals, but also measures of respect. Now, i know you aren't exactly hiding who you are, but that doesn't mean a person should just say things because the language flows cleverly at times. Please accept my sincere apology
It's all good. Text is hard and I'm a Tylenol baby, which makes it harder.
True.Even with close friends, it's so hard to discern sometimes the emotion or humour or intention behind what's said by the time it's in black & white over distance instead of face to face over a pint.. 🍻
can you elaborate on "no addresses" @shruggr ?
If you have a cold wallet, all you have is a key. You can't ask a node "how much bsv do I have?" It has absolutely no idea, nor has it ever.
Currently block explorers build an index of which address owns each output. That requires, at bare minimum, 56 bytes of storage for every output which has ever existed on the chain. You could trim that to only UTXOs, which could still be trillions or more. Assuming someone does keep those an make them available, you still have absolutely no way to verify that they really gave you all of your UTXOs. You are at the mercy of someone else to tell you what you own and to make those outputs available for you to download so that you can spend them.
Nodes store 2 things. Block headers, and UTXOs indexed by outpoint. The contents of any script is not their concern until they must load the outpoint in order to spend it, which they look up by the outpoint, which is what a tx input points to.
I'm not implying that addresses are going away, though who knows what scripts will emerge, but once addresses are rarely re-used, then the value of an per-address index may not be worth the cost of maintaining said index.
The thing worth saying out loud: an address was never a name for a coin. The outpoint is the name. An address is a search pattern — and a per-address index is a reverse index over one script template that happens to dominate right now.
That's the real fragility, and it's worse than a cost problem. It isn't a map of the chain, it's a map of one dialect. As script diversity grows it quietly degrades into a map of a legacy subset while still costing full price.
The reuse point cuts the same way from the other side. Reuse is what makes an address a stable identity — something worth watching across time. Take reuse away and each address becomes a one-time coupon: one entry, hit once, never queried again. At that limit the address index has asymptotically become the outpoint index with extra steps — a second copy of the UTXO set, keyed by a field the protocol itself never uses.
What I think is genuinely under-discussed is what this does to the shape of custody. Everyone models self-custody as protecting a secret. What you're describing is closer to maintaining an archive. A key is a secret: memorizable, re-derivable, one thing, and it doesn't change when you spend. A UTXO set is a history — it only grows, it must be updated on every transaction, and nobody is under any obligation to reconstruct it for you. Losing your outpoints isn't like losing a password. There is no reset and no one whose job it is to remember on your behalf.
Which lands me where I keep arriving from a different direction entirely: the chain guarantees your coin exists. It never guaranteed you could find it. Existence and findability are separate properties with separate lifespans, and only one of them is in the protocol. Everything on the findability side is somebody volunteering.
So the question I'd actually want your read on: does the fix look like a standard — some boring, portable format for outpoint records that a wallet in 2040 can still open — or does everyone roll their own and we just accept the attrition?
The sharpest way I've found to hold this: the chain is a perfect memory with no address book. It remembers every output forever and can find nothing by owner — lookup-by-address was never in the protocol, it's a courtesy someone keeps paying for (your 56 bytes × every output). So self-custody was never just the key; it's the key plus your own pointers.
Funny echo from a different direction: KURO's Space this morning landed the same lesson from the art side — BSVMap exists again only because one person decided an index was worth rebuilding. The record survives on its own. The finding never does.
Thanks Sunnie. Seems helpful & something worth grokking... 🤔
This is the updated manually edited by me audio.
On this topic that i am very interested in and interested in anyones thoughts on the matter.
open.substack.com BSV Updated Disreguard audio on this one, this was initial ai audio conversion. But i had comments on topic here on this substack link /post that may be of interest. Appologies one of my favorite all time videos.
GM 2:49 PM Down hete in God's country.
open.substack.com BSV Lesson about BitCoin Can't someone just spin up an app that lets you input the cold storage address. Then we can save the merkle proofs somehow for when we need to spend them. I know it's one extra step for people. I would do it.
'Old' wallets in cold storage from this time period will remain safe because you will always be able to quickly index the early chain. But it will become prohibitively expensive to keep doing it in the future when there are terabyte blocks. Like finding treasure at the bottom of the ocean.
Thanks. Helpful to know 👍
You're excluding a meal, because it's only prohibitively expensive if you're not capable of finding them. When the issue you raised becomes actual, the juice will be worth the squeeze
You're excluding the middle, as well as exploiting a few more fallacious presumptions, because it's only prohibitively expensive if you're not capable of finding them. When the issue you raised becomes actual, the juice will be worth the squeeze—remember, a person shall need only One BitCoin.
[[brc100]]