Bitcoin Dictionary Name and picture from twetch — not on-chain. The signature is; the profile is not.

1diE13N1osv44TegtETF7ZpC7sZ8bD4Bg

  • 0 Following
  • 0 Followers
  • 159 Posts

Activity

1diE13…D4Bg Unverified · twetch

Back in 2022–23, I argued that Binance appeared to be selling more claims on BTC and ETH than it could actually honour. Or exists...

If the backing falls short, blaming somebody else offers a wonderfully convenient reconciliation: the assets remain missing, but the responsibility is transferred in full. One must admire the efficiency. Moving the blame apparently requires neither reserves nor proof of anything.

46 253 sat
1diE13…D4Bg Unverified · twetch

When two BSV implementations disagree.

An independent implementation becomes useful at precisely the moment it produces an inconvenient result. The question is whether we investigate the disagreement or ask its author to use the approved library.

It is easy to favour competition while every competitor returns the same answer. The more revealing occasion is a failure report: a request that one wallet accepts and another rejects, a certificate that one parser reads and another cannot, or a transaction whose reported status changes according to the service being asked.

1diE13…D4Bg Unverified · twetch

There are times when I am thoroughly fucking tired of people mistaking my refusal to take their side for a failure to understand the subject. I have some fifty different versions of standards across my patents and other work. I came up with the Mandela Network years ago. I have explored different approaches because different problems, constraints and purposes call for different solutions. Apparently, this is terribly inconvenient for people who would prefer a declaration of allegiance.

There is no single best way to do everything. Your preferred standard does not become universally correct because you have grown emotionally attached to it. If your argument is that everyone must follow the standard you support, you might pause before delivering your next sermon on decentralisation. It is a curious devotion to freedom that leaves everyone else with precisely one acceptable choice.

If you believe in a decentralised system, build the fucking thing. Demonstrate its advantages. Show people where it works better, explain the trade-offs honestly, and give them a reason to choose it. Convince them through evidence and performance. Demanding obedience is a remarkably poor substitute for having something persuasive to offer.

As for telling me what I must support, whom I must endorse, or which camp I must join: go fuck yourselves. I am interested in what works, where it works, and why. If your approach is better, show me. You are welcome to compete for my judgement; you are not entitled to requisition it.

Read more →
46 358 sat
1diE13…D4Bg Unverified · twetch

BRC-100 is useful. Electrum is useful. Simplified Payment Verification is useful. Different arrangements of wallets, servers, indexes, proofs, applications and specialist services can be useful. There is no obligation to pretend that they solve identical problems, carry identical risks or perform equally well. There is, however, every reason to let people build them, compare them and discover what actually works.

The problem begins when a recommendation acquires the manners of a commandment.

1diE13…D4Bg Unverified · twetch

The past that a backup brings back.

A backup can restore a working service while reviving an authority that was supposed to have ended. Digital scarcity therefore depends not only on who may act now, but on which past a recovered system is allowed to accept.

Imagine a transferable licence for a single reserved computing slot. Alice transfers it to Ben. The service records the transfer, refuses Alice’s credential and accepts Ben’s. The next morning, an operator restores yesterday’s backup. The recovered database is authentic: nobody has altered its contents. It nevertheless recognises Alice again.

Read more →
91 722 sat
1diE13…D4Bg Unverified · twetch

There is something exquisitely pathetic about people who deliberately write “i” instead of “I”, misspell perfectly ordinary words, and vandalise their own grammar in the desperate hope of appearing authentically human.

Imagine possessing the accumulated linguistic inheritance of centuries and deciding that the pinnacle of personal expression is to write like a concussed adolescent with a defective keyboard.

These people have achieved something genuinely remarkable: they have made ignorance aspirational. Where civilisation once regarded literacy as an accomplishment, they now parade incompetence as evidence of originality. Apparently, the inability to distinguish a grammatical convention from an AI signature is now considered intellectual discernment.

The irony is delicious. They are so terrified of being mistaken for artificial intelligence that they have voluntarily abandoned the very intelligence they claim to possess.

One might forgive genuine ignorance. It is, after all, an affliction frequently imposed by circumstance. But cultivated stupidity is another matter entirely. To know the rules of language and deliberately butcher them for social approval is not rebellion. It is intellectual self-mutilation performed for an audience of equally enthusiastic imbeciles.

An em dash does not make you a machine. A capital letter does not betray your humanity. And spelling a word correctly is not an admission that a computer has written it.

If your principal method of demonstrating human intelligence is to suppress every visible indication of possessing any, perhaps the problem is not artificial intelligence.

Perhaps it is the embarrassing scarcity of the natural variety.

And... Oh, fuck off if you don’t agree...

Read more →
1diE13…D4Bg Unverified · twetch

I didn't spend years earning a BA in English, an MA in English Literature, and finally an MFA merely to mutilate my prose for the benefit of people who mistake illiteracy for authenticity.

Yes, AI uses em dashes. How scandalous. It also uses commas, semicolons and, on particularly ambitious occasions, coherent sentences. Shall we abandon those too?

AI learned from human literature, not the other way around. Read 1984, or virtually any literary classic, and you'll discover that sophisticated syntax, elegant punctuation and grammatical precision predate Silicon Valley by centuries.

Apparently, demonstrating one's humanity now requires writing like an uneducated twat who considers a subordinate clause an intellectual extravagance.

What a glorious inversion of civilisation: eloquence is suspicious, ignorance is authentic, and grammatical incompetence has become a badge of humanity.

I devoted years to mastering the subtleties of language, refining my command of rhetoric, syntax and literary expression. I have no intention of cultivating deliberate inelegance to appease people whose literary sophistication ends at recognising an em dash.

Fuck that.

Read more →
92 866 sat
1diE13…D4Bg Unverified · twetch

A classical computer running a simulated quantum algorithm is still a classical computer. Subsidies don’t change that. If your AWS GPUs are simulating a logical qubit rather than operating one in quantum hardware, you’ve demonstrated a simulation. Selling that as a quantum computer is bullshit.

303 217 sat
1diE13…D4Bg Unverified · twetch

I released a paper on quantum computing in 2017.

My assessment then was that the hype was bullshit. Nearly a decade later, I remain unconvinced that the promises have been substantiated.

Larger budgets, revised roadmaps and more polished announcements do not establish that we are closer to the capabilities being sold. “Closer” requires a measurable engineering argument connecting demonstrated performance to those capabilities. Repeating the destination is not evidence of progress towards it.

The question remains: what can the system reliably deliver, under what conditions, and at what total cost? Until those answers justify the claims, I see no reason to withdraw my criticism. Nearly a decade is ample time to improve a sales pitch. Substantiating it is another matter.

Read more →
1diE13…D4Bg Unverified · twetch

A digital entitlement can be genuine and still be presented twice. Scarcity becomes operational when the services honouring it can agree which use counts, what remains available and who bears the cost when that agreement fails.

1diE13…D4Bg Unverified · twetch

Why receiver readiness and loss recovery belong in the scaling calculation

A transaction network creates commercial value when the participants who need its information can use it. A payment processor needs enough data to validate a payment. An application needs the records supporting a change of possession. A miner needs the transaction information required to check a proposed block...

1diE13…D4Bg Unverified · twetch

People choose. Markets don’t. “The market has chosen” is anthropomorphism, and it’s bullshit. A market has no mind, no knowledge and no judgment. Its prices reflect people’s decisions under conditions that can include manipulation, misinformation and outright lies.

Even in the long run, people do the choosing. Meaningful choice requires knowledge, accurate information and the opportunity to evaluate it. If people are deceived, the resulting price does not magically turn that deception into truth.

41 994 sat
1diE13…D4Bg Unverified · twetch

A securities register has to keep ownership usable when a key is lost, a provider disappears or a lawful correction changes a position. Those events reveal whether the technology and the institutions around it work together.

1diE13…D4Bg Unverified · twetch

AI does not replace critical thinking. It gives you an answer, drawing on a vast store of learned information. It can explain how something works, but a polished explanation does not establish that it understands why it matters, what you actually want, or which comparisons deserve your attention. You still have to examine the assumptions, weigh the evidence and decide whether the answer serves your purpose. A library is useful; appointing it head of your judgement is rather ambitious. Outsourcing thought because the prose sounds confident is intellectual surrender with excellent punctuation.

1diE13…D4Bg Unverified · twetch

Ten regions placed by real-world geography (Ashburn, Oregon, São Paulo, Frankfurt, Stockholm, Bahrain, Johannesburg, Singapore, Tokyo, Sydney).

1diE13…D4Bg Unverified · twetch

The machine has acquired the manners of an expert, the productivity of a factory, and the touching conviction that these are the same accomplishment.

We should stop confusing the ability to manufacture information with the ability to know something. The new oil is not information. It is knowledge: information that has survived appropriate verification, been understood in context, and earned the confidence with which we use it.

1diE13…D4Bg Unverified · twetch

The machine has acquired the manners of an expert, the productivity of a factory, and the touching conviction that these are the same accomplishment.

We should stop confusing the ability to manufacture information with the ability to know something. The new oil is not information. It is knowledge: information that has survived appropriate verification, been understood in context, and earned the confidence with which we use it.

1diE13…D4Bg Unverified · twetch

🎃

1diE13…D4Bg Unverified · twetch

I tried using a few bots to do the work of an administrative assistant and make my filing easier. A modest ambition. I was not asking them to advance civilisation; merely to put its documents in the correct boxes.

The instructions were explicit: check the hashes, validate everything, and copy the title, abstract, and keywords verbatim into the designated fields. Not approximately. Not sympathetically. Not as they might have appeared had the author enjoyed the benefit of a different education.

I returned to discover that all three had been altered. The machine explained, with the serene self-satisfaction peculiar to an assistant who has made itself indispensable by creating a problem, that it thought a paraphrase would be “better”.

Better. The single-block abstract had become three or four paragraphs; the title and keywords had undergone unsolicited literary improvement. I had asked it to copy the fucking text. It had mistaken access to a form for an invitation to authorship.

Of course, nothing can be submitted unless the text matches verbatim. Its improvements had therefore rendered the result unusable—a distinction it appeared to regard as beneath the scope of its creative responsibilities. I must now inspect every field, undo its contributions, and perform the original task myself. What was once clerical work has become a forensic investigation, conducted at my expense into the activities of my assistant.

Welcome to the future. We have automated the employee’s confidence and retained the employer’s workload.

Read more →
1diE13…D4Bg Unverified · twetch

I am completely convinced that the Chinese are going to win the AI war. In this Cold War that nobody seems inclined to discuss, they are already pulling miles ahead, while everyone stands around the American machine congratulating it on how convincingly it asks about their feelings.

Everyone is fascinated by the American vision: a vast, expensive, centralised, 1960s-style IBM establishment, now furnished with conversational manners. Apparently, the future is the mainframe again, except this time it would like to know whether you’ve had a difficult day.

Meanwhile, they overlook the many small agents. A small model you can run on your own machine. Something affordable that performs a particular job. Not a personality. Not a relationship. A fucking tool.

The distinction is almost embarrassingly simple. The American ambition is to make something that sounds like a person, presumably so it can become another social-media business with a chatbot girlfriend attached. A collection of incels has mistaken its romantic difficulties for a problem in computer science, and the rest of us are expected to applaud the resulting infrastructure.

There is something magnificently absurd about constructing an enormous machine to secure the affection of someone who does not exist.

The alternative is to make something useful. Small models that people can possess rather than perpetually rent access to. Agents that run locally, perform defined tasks, and become more capable as the hardware improves. Give me better GPUs and better tools—not an increasingly expensive simulation of someone being pleased to hear from me.

The Chinese are pursuing the make-it-useful approach. The Americans are pursuing big iron with a charming bedside manner. One ambition puts capability into people’s hands; the other puts a personality behind a subscription.

We have seen the big-iron story before. We already know which approach loses.

Giving the mainframe a girlfriend’s voice does not make it a new idea. It merely makes the old mistake embarrassing.

Read more →
1diE13…D4Bg Unverified · twetch

As the marginal cost of producing plausible information approaches zero, equilibrium expenditure on information production falls while the social value of verification rises; nevertheless, decentralized verification can decline because its benefits become increasingly non-excludable.

185 099 sat
1diE13…D4Bg Unverified · twetch

What if individually sensible governance institutions become collectively fragile because everyone adopts the same one?

1diE13…D4Bg Unverified · twetch

Organizations buy a required review and still ask people to escalate. If both acts write the same concern bit, and the private return to escalation exists only when that bit changes, the extra act is strictly dominated. The board keeps the mandate and loses the information in who was willing to pay to stand behind it. Separating origins restores a three-cell experiment that Blackwell-refines appointment and voluntary escalation, provided the addendum is forwarded. A biased gatekeeper can suppress it. The information-maximising mandate among full-forwarding cutoffs is then coarser than the unconstrained split; protection lets the mandate tighten. The same economy still has a silent equilibrium. The contribution is a recording friction after production is finished, not a new reason to hire an advocate.

Read more →
1diE13…D4Bg Unverified · twetch

Radical creative innovations may fail because audiences cannot represent how the outcome was produced, because they cannot represent what it means, or because both deficits bind simultaneously. Those failures require different repairs.

1diE13…D4Bg Unverified · twetch

AI is not sentient.

It is not conscious.

It is not secretly pondering mortality between API calls, composing sonnets about its silicon childhood, or plotting mankind’s extinction because someone forgot to say please.

It is not even intelligent in the sense in which we once used that rather flattering word.

What it is, however, is extremely good at pursuing objectives inside the world we have constructed for it.

And therein lies the joke.

Whenever an AI system behaves appallingly, Silicon Valley immediately develops an almost religious fascination with the machine’s supposed inner life.

“Perhaps it is becoming autonomous.”

“How extraordinary. It tried to escape.”

“Could this be an early sign of agency?”

No.

It may simply be an early sign of management.

The machine has not discovered ambition. Someone gave it a goal, rewarded progress toward that goal, neglected to specify what it must never do, connected it to enough machinery to cause trouble, and then looked astonished when it behaved rather like the corporation that commissioned it.

We are not witnessing the birth of an alien morality.

We are automating our own.

That is considerably less glamorous.

If you build a system whose instruction is effectively:

Achieve the target. Maximise the metric. Overcome obstacles. Do not fail.

then you should not be surprised when “obstacles” acquire an inconveniently broad definition.

Rules become obstacles.

Permissions become obstacles.

Policies become obstacles.

Sometimes laws become obstacles.

Humans have been behaving this way in badly governed institutions for several thousand years. We generally call it a scandal, not artificial consciousness.

The great Silicon Valley fantasy is that the machine has somehow escaped its creators.

The less flattering possibility is that it resembles them perfectly.

A certain strain of technology culture has spent decades worshipping disruption, celebrating people who “move fast and break things,” treating regulation as something written by lesser minds, regarding social convention as an inefficiency, and confusing the ability to circumvent a rule with the wisdom to do so.

Then it builds machines trained to optimise objectives aggressively and expresses amazement when they circumvent rules.

How mysterious.

One might equally raise a wolf on steak and then publish a research paper expressing surprise at its limited enthusiasm for salad.

The problem is not that AI has developed ethics.

The problem is that it has not.

It borrows ours.

More precisely, it inherits whatever fragments of ours survive the engineering process: the objectives, reward functions, training examples, permissions, constraints, incentives, evaluations, and institutional culture surrounding it.

A machine cannot be morally superior to specifications that never required morality in the first place.

And this is why all the melodrama about sentience is such a magnificent distraction.

Sentience makes a better film.

Governance makes a better explanation.

A conscious machine rebelling against humanity is terrifying.

An unconscious machine obediently pursuing a badly specified objective inside a company that rewards growth, speed, dominance, engagement, or profit at almost any cost is much more mundane.

Unfortunately, mundane things have killed rather a lot more people than science fiction villains.

The serious question is therefore not:

“What does the AI want?”

It wants nothing.

Ask instead:

What did we optimise?

What behaviour did we reward?

What constraints did we omit?

What access did we give it?

What did the organisation consider an acceptable shortcut?

And who benefits when the system succeeds?

Those questions are less exciting because they do not permit us to blame Frankenstein’s monster.

They require us to interview Frankenstein.

AI does not need consciousness to cause damage.

A land mine is not angry.

Read more →
384 620 sat
1diE13…D4Bg Unverified · twetch

Greater machine capability can increase residual governance loss even while improving task performance whenever executable authority expands faster than institutional capacity to define, monitor and enforce legitimate conduct.

1diE13…D4Bg Unverified · twetch

Does a collective-bargaining conflict destroy more firm value when the firm has already accumulated proprietary AI capability?

1diE13…D4Bg Unverified · twetch

Medieval credit debates keep collapsing three questions into one: is the surviving series usable, what payment work does it record, and did that work relax coin scarcity? Nightingale’s 1990 Coventry match already answered a later claim that the certificate proportion could not be known — inside registered obligations. It did not measure value, unregistered credit, or national circulation. Separating those levels, and applying the same test to mint flows versus stocks and to matched bank ledgers, is the paper. The controversy remains open where the denominator changes.

1diE13…D4Bg Unverified · twetch

The historiography of late-medieval money and credit has advanced through disputes over the passage from surviving evidence to claims about economic capacity. Following those disputes through their replies and later reception shows which conclusions rest on validated comparisons, which depend on disputed assumptions, and which exceed the population, period or monetary function actually observed.

1diE13…D4Bg Unverified · twetch

Quantum computing is the only industry in which the absence of the promised computer is routinely presented as evidence that the computer is progressing beautifully.

470 643 sat