One of the ways to answer 0!=1 in math is by "completing the pattern" (4!=5!/5, 3!=4!/4... 0!=1!/1) but if you complete the pattern in the opposite direction going from negative numbers(-4!= -5!/5, -3!=-4!/4)... 0! = -1?
Is this incompleteness?
Post by twetch#21877
Yeah, not so sure about that. The factorial is defined on positive integers by induction. What value to assign the base case of 0 is in a sense a free choice, but you know you'll always want 0!=1 for binomial theorem, etc...
What the chain says
- Block
- 634 722
- Time
- 2020-05-13T06:32:53Z
- Signer
- 16SgJCRH7fB5ny6wCHabmiGaa6wcbve6WS
- App
- twetch
- Type
- post
- Content type
- text/plain
- Name in tx
- twetch#21877
Fields the transaction did not carry are omitted. Open the payload to see the bytes as stored.
16SgJCRH7fB5ny6wCHabmiGaa6wcbve6WS VerifiedReplies (3)
As it turns out, of the countably many continuous extensions of factorial to C, there is a unique meromorphic log convex one called the gamma function, but even she has poles at all negative integers. There really is a problem with thinking -1!=0!/0.
Thanks for the clarification, I need to read up on my definitions! I'm no mathematician by any means but i do find philosophy of mathematics very interesting.
I would certainly agree. I strongly recommend the book Proofs and Refutations by Imre Lakatos if you haven't read it. It's rather accessible and a gem!