Here is the whole thread:
On BRC-100
0/ There's a small team being paid to build ecosystem infrastructure, so resource constraints are real. In my opinion, the intentions are sound, and what they are attempting is difficult.
1/ "BRC-100 is too complicated for users" I've heard this said often and I agree - It is. I think the push by the BSVA was too fast & hard for what I consider an experimental framework. But the BSV 'community' is small.
2/ And 'small' is perhaps the point. BSV wants to scale to millions/billions of tps eventually. Whatever handles identity and payment authorization at that volume needs to already work before the volume shows up, not get debugged live.
3/ Right now, while we're small, is the perfect time to find BRC-100's problems. A bug that annoys a user today is a disaster at real scale. Yes - users are guinea pigs (don't put a lot of BSV on these wallets) and I think the people building it should own that.
4/ What BRC-100 actually does: it fuses wallet, auth, payment, and identity under one root key. A payment can prove who sent it with no password. A login can happen with no account database to breach.
5/ In practice: a store could recognize you as a returning customer, issue you a refund, or resolve a dispute, all without an account or a password, because it's tied to the same key you already used to pay them.
6/ Only the person you paid can tell it's you. Nobody else can link a payment back to your identity.
7/ Split wallet, auth, payment, and identity into separate "simpler" standards and you lose why they were fused together in one key in the first place.
8/ None of this is all-or-nothing. You can use just the identity piece to sign and prove who you are with no payment attached at all. Or skip identity completely: a plain address with nothing linked to it still works, and always will - which is not BRC-100.
9/ "Too complicated for users" is true of the implemented BRC-100 wallets today. It says nothing about whether the spec underneath is right.
10/ One example: most stock wallets I've used treat you as the same identity everywhere, even though the BRC-100 spec lets you derive a different, unlinkable ID key for every context. That's a wallet choice, not a BRC-100 limit.
11/ The spec is 1.0, but we're very early. I think the primitives are necessary for what needs to exist at scale. I think wallet UX is where the real work needs to happen. Whether the spec itself needs tweaks, I'm not qualified to say yet. I'm going to keep experimenting on this.