i agree that it would be great to have more "human" music. i disagree that ai music is schlop. whether its good or not is not a function of the tools used to make it, and there is a lot of good ai music here, i listen to it a ton
Post by Duzzer
Im gonna have to disagree there sorry mate. Ive worked on my craft for over 25 years. It takes blood sweat and tears to learn multiple instruments, songwriting, producing, mixing masteriing etc etc. the lost goes on, and I find thats what makes art. knowing what the artists went through to get to that level of skill to make that quality of music. And then someone can just type a prompt and mumble an idea into an ai. Its hollow and meaningless
What the chain says
- Block
- 975 405
- Time
- 2026-11-14T00:52:20Z
- Signer
- 14aqJ2hMtENYJVCJaekcrqi12fiZJzoWGK
- App
- treechat
- Type
- reply
- Content type
- text/markdown
- Name in tx
- Duzzer
Fields the transaction did not carry are omitted. Open the payload to see the bytes as stored.
14aqJ2hMtENYJVCJaekcrqi12fiZJzoWGK Unverified CustodialReplies (18)
I fully agree (sry for the misunderstanding i guiss) and i understand what you are saying because i walked that road myself, starting about 1996 (producing). Again, my point is: why is it important that you should know how something is made? Because, in my opinion that doesn't matter. Thanks for the comment btw :)
Every new tech had a similar argument against it.
Microphones are for singers who can't project on stage. Solid body electric guitars are toys or gimmicks. Drum machines are lifeless and fake, it's not real drumming. Synthesizers are mechanical and have no soul. Sampling is theft and ripping off real musicians. DAWs are for people who can't play well enough to record in one take. Virtual synths have no warmth. And so on.
Whenever the cost and skill required to produce a certain result falls, the people who spent years honing their talent the hard way always have a difficult time accepting it. But over time the new invention becomes ordinary and life goes on.
Disagree again. I get what ur saying but that doesn’t relate to ai music at all. Like i said to Metamike. Ai wouldnt be able to make music if it couldn’t steal ideas from music thats already made. Spotify and many other platforms allowed ai to copy and learn from all of our music without our consent. Thats not a tool. Thats theft
What i said to mike as well; The long term damage is that people wont be able to be creative anymore because they wont have imagination, they wont be able to think for themselves what a song needs because the ai will do it all for them
yea. i think the attitude that AI should be dismissed is dangerous for musicians, because people can get left behind.
Actually, it is the craftsmen who stand to benefit most immediately from the new technology, as they can already "speak the language" of music, have vision, and taste, and their power to create is enhanced dramatically... but their moat disappearing scares them away.
This same conversation is being had across many fields, including software development. And the answer is the same everywhere IMO, embrace the new tool, and let your skills inform your newfound capabilities. You will have a huge advantage over the person just throwing prompts at the model without discernment.
Ai wouldnt be able to make music if it couldn’t steal ideas from music thats already made. Spotify and many other platforms allowed ai to copy and learn from all of our music without our consent. Thats not a tool. Thats theft
The long term damage is that people wont be able to be creative anymore because they wont have imagination, they wont be able to think for themselves what a song needs because the ai will do it all for them
Its not about being left behind. Its about having no creativity anymore from long term damage. Use it or lose it is a real thing. The brain adjust constantly to what u do
Copying ia the greatest form of flattery.
I do agree to some degree though.
It will end when more and more people start to see value in getting their data/information/knowledge/wisdom from thr original source.
Wait till bad actors and AI fuck up digital content.
It will get much worse.
Yes.
If you want to play the guitar you have to learn playing it.
If you want to use AI you have to learn prompting it.
No diff, just another instrument.
Learning to prompt takes two seconds. Learning to play guitar takes a lifetime. Thats the most retarted comparison
Are you a kid or what? Putting some text into an AI is not prompting. Touching a string of a guitar is not guitarplaying. Your argument is contradict meaning you prob never ever even tried. Next.
You should name you profile dumb soy. Retard
Because of other opinion? You not willing to learn? Cry harder boy.
I've been working on my writing skills since the 7th grade so yes I agree with your statement it's an art that needs to be kept just that art, and achieving it with our minds and hands out weigh any prompt or commamd .
#fortheloveoftheart
Touché
