Post by Bitcoin Dictionary

1diE13…D4Bg Unverified · twetch

GDP: The Economic Miracle of Producing Less and Calling It Growth

GDP is one of the most misleading measures ever elevated to the status of economic truth. It measures monetary value added, not how much useful production an economy actually delivers.

Consider a simple example.

We have 100 cars being produced. We then employ another 100 people checking, certifying, verifying, regulating, documenting and administering those cars.

Nothing additional has been produced. We still have 100 cars.

But all that bureaucracy costs money. The certificates cost money. The regulatory procedures cost money. The compliance systems cost money.

The resulting cars become more expensive, and GDP can record a greater monetary value.

Let's say total GDP is now 300 units.

Now consider a different economy.

Instead of employing those people to supervise production, we put them to work producing another 100 cars. We now have 200 cars rather than 100. We might even have 50 people doing nothing.

Actual production has doubled.

But suppose the total monetary value of that output is only 200 units.

According to GDP, the first economy is 50% larger.

One economy produces 100 cars and records GDP of 300. The other produces 200 cars and records GDP of 200.

The GDP figures are consistent with the first economy being larger in monetary terms, despite producing half as many cars.

And therein lies the problem.

We've confused expenditure, prices and monetary value added with the physical production of goods and services.

The economy employing armies of administrators can appear more productive in GDP terms than the economy delivering twice the number of actual products.

GDP does not tell us whether the additional expenditure created genuine economic benefits or simply made existing production more expensive.

That distinction matters enormously.

A government can expand regulatory requirements, increase administrative expenditure, employ more compliance officers and generate additional measured economic activity without increasing the quantity of useful goods delivered.

Meanwhile, technological improvements that allow us to produce the same goods more cheaply can reduce measured expenditure even while making society materially better off.

Producing more with fewer resources is an economic achievement. Making the same output more expensive is not.

Yet GDP can make the second look more impressive than the first.

This is why governments love GDP. It allows expenditure and expanding administration to be presented as economic success without answering the question that actually matters.

What have we produced? How much more can people consume? How efficiently have we transformed scarce resources into useful output?

Those are economic questions.

Simply adding monetary transactions and value added together does not answer them.

GDP is an accounting measure. Treating it as a comprehensive measure of productivity, efficiency or prosperity is an extraordinary intellectual mistake.

An economy does not become more productive because it employs more people to count, certify and regulate the same number of cars.

Sometimes the greatest economic achievement is producing twice as much while spending considerably less.

And sometimes the greatest political achievement is making the statistics look better while producing absolutely nothing additional.

GDP is exceptionally convenient for the latter.

The bureaucracy gets bigger. The cars get dearer. GDP goes up. And everyone congratulates the government on economic growth.

What an extraordinary system of bullshit.

What the chain says
Block
975 553
Time
2026-11-15T03:00:10Z
Signer
1diE13N1osv44TegtETF7ZpC7sZ8bD4Bg
App
twetch
Type
post
Content type
text/markdown

Fields the transaction did not carry are omitted. Open the payload to see the bytes as stored.

Signed by 1diE13N1osv44TegtETF7ZpC7sZ8bD4Bg Unverified