Roger leaves out important details and events and gets the tech wrong on multiple occasions, but it's a mostly accurate retelling of what went down.
As a historical document of the blocksize war and the hijacking of Bitcoin, it's valuable. As a prescription for what to do about it, it fails.
What Roger got right:
• The history of the blocksize war is meticulously
documented and largely accurate
• The censorship campaign (r/bitcoin, Bitcointalk, Dragon's Den) was real and coordinated
• Blockstream's conflicts of interest are well evidenced
• The NYA betrayal and SegWit2x failure are accurately told
• The diagnosis that Bitcoin was captured through developer centralization, narrative control, and economic pressure is correct
What Roger got wrong:
• He prescribes BCH as the cure while BCH exhibits the same disease (developer capture attempts, protocol instability, repeated forks)
• He treats BSV as a footnote defined by Craig Wright' personality rather than engaging with its technical reality
• He applies the censorship/suppression framework inconsistently documenting it when applied to big blockers and BCH, ignoring it when applied to BSV
• His "conclusion" principles (lock the protocol,
remove block limit, focus on cash, resist developer capture) describe BSV, not BCH
• He gets technical details wrong or oversimplifies them throughout. He admits he's not a programmer, and it shows. Scaling is treated as a policy decision rather than an engineering problem. Protocol changes are celebrated or condemned based on who made them, not on their technical merit.
The tragedy of the book:
Roger Ver correctly identified that Bitcoin was hijacked. He correctly identified the mechanisms: developer capture, censorship, narrative control, economic coercion. He correctly identified what the solution looks like: a stable protocol, unlimited blocks, peer-to-peer cash, miner-driven governance. Then he refused to acknowledge the chain that actually implemented all of it, because he couldn't separate the technology from his personal conflict with Craig Wright. The book is an accidentally perfect argument for BSV, written by someone who would never admit it.