Logical summary of all three files
1. Collin Cleary, “What Socialism Is (and Isn’t),” Part 1
Core definition. Cleary argues that “socialism” is uselessly debated because almost no one defines it. He rejects the common identification of socialism with Marxism, worker revolution, state ownership, or central planning. Instead, he says socialism has two essential beliefs:
- There is a common good that government/society must serve.
- Unbridled capitalism ultimately undermines that common good.
Both are required. Belief in a common good alone is not socialism—Aristotle isn’t a socialist. Socialism is specifically a modern response to capitalism and liberalism. Liberalism, in his broad sense, denies the common good and treats society as individuals pursuing private goods; Margaret Thatcher’s “no such thing as society” is his example. Capitalism was supposed to harmonize selfish interests, but Cleary claims it actually destroys cultural identity, industry, small business, self-employment, families, communities, and free speech through globalism, corporate concentration, multiculturalism, and “vulture capitalism.”
Socialism vs. conservatism. Cleary argues that “conservative capitalist” is a contradiction. Real conservatism values tradition, locality, tribe, family, and inherited identity; capitalism is a permanent revolution that melts “all that is solid into air,” as Marx said. Capitalism commodifies everything, including people, religion, and education, and creates a global monoculture. Therefore, so-called conservatives who defend capitalism while opposing abortion, drag shows, etc. are inconsistent: capitalism is far more destructive to families and communities than those cultural issues. He calls Nixon, Reagan, Bush, Bush II, and Thatcher fake conservatives, and says Trump’s rise reflects popular recognition that establishment Republicans pursued open borders and globalist economics that harmed working Americans. Populism is groping toward a “third position.”
Viable socialism. Cleary sketches a “conservative socialism”:
- Private ownership remains, but owners are answerable to the state for product quality, social impact, and treatment of employees.
- The state may direct, restrict, or halt production for the common good.
- A fascist-style corporatism: employers and employees organized into industry syndicates under state supervision, setting wages, production priorities, prices, and economic policy with legal force.
- The aim is class reconciliation and national interest, not class conflict.
- Autarchy/self-sufficiency, protectionism, tariffs, domestic manufacturing, restrictions on offshoring; globalism renounced.
- A robust social minimum: safety net, healthcare for those unable to pay, labor-hour limits, workplace standards, paid vacation, free/low-cost education from kindergarten through professional school.
- Progressive taxation with loopholes closed; limits on wealth and ownership; antitrust laws; restrictions on media consolidation; laws against conspicuous consumption.
- He explicitly rejects “growth,” “competitiveness,” and GDP as supreme goods. A nation is not a sports team; the goal is preserving culture and people.
Race and “diversity.” Cleary argues socialism is only viable in a racially homogeneous ethnostate. He claims genetic similarity theory shows people care most for their own kind, and that welfare states work best when recipients are racially similar. He asserts whites resist socialism because they fear blacks will benefit; makes racially charged claims about blacks and welfare dependency; says white liberals are “freakish” for not loving their own; and argues homogeneity produces trust, shame, and willingness to pay for social programs. He cites “Swedish-style socialism” as having worked because Swedes were homogeneous and high-trust, but now is burdened by migration. He concludes: in the socialist ethnostate, you pay for the welfare state out of love of your own.
2. Comment thread on Part 1
The comments are mostly supportive and expand on Cleary’s themes:
- Vagrant Rightist: praises the article; says misuse of language keeps people stupid; the John Birch Society misled the right; conservatives are fooled into celebrating tax breaks for Zuckerberg; capitalism has long colluded with the radical left (LGBT flag as symbol); the “Hitler was a leftist because of ‘socialism’” argument is stupid; he is fine calling himself a national socialist.
- Collin Cleary replies that he may write an article on the “Hitler was a Leftist” argument and that Part 2 is coming.
- E_Perez: says the elephant in the room for “conservative socialism” is National Socialism, German or Chinese.
- Joe Gould: says the elephant in national socialism is war—no way to stop the top man from launching a harmful war—but American democracy now has the same problem.
- Box Hill: cites Hitler quotation on the cover of George Watson’s The Lost Literature of Socialism: “How, as a socialist, can you not be an anti-Semite?”
- Joseph C.: says libertarianism is spreading across South America because the right lacks ethnic homogeneity and needs a colorblind doctrine; there is a leftist wave; right-wing cadres lack education and copy the US; Milei is popular and Jewish.
- Guest (white nationalist from Eastern Europe): says if forced to choose between current capitalism and communism, he would choose communism; today’s capitalism is a decadent “kakistocracy”; libertarianism is poison to the white right; America has no narrative but capitalism; that alternative died with the Confederacy.
- Elear: says Soviet socialism created a technical intelligentsia and industrialized agrarian Eastern Europe; internal passports and factory allocation slowed rootlessness; post-communist rust belts and real-estate mafias degraded cities; libertarianism destroyed care for beauty and good living.
- Joe Gould: says socialism has been “anti-racist”/anti-white, but pro-whites now need to discuss taboo “socialist” ideas; wealthy non-Whites organize racially while wealthy whites don’t; whites need a common-good system to avoid “all power to the Epstein class.”
- TYRS HAND: recovering libertarian; praises Benoist on capitalism destroying traditionalism; hopes the “Great Reset” turns in their favor.
- Ultrarightist: challenges the article from an anti-socialist view; asks why equality and opposition to private property were not listed as fundamental socialist tenets; asks whether pre-capitalist systems like feudalism were socialist. Cleary replies that private property remains but state controls its use; equality means equality before law and access to healthcare/education, not enforced wealth equality; Italian Fascism and National Socialism were similar to his model.
- Lord Snooty: cites G.B. Shaw’s postal-service argument for nationalization; notes the postwar edition removed “Sovietism and Fascism” chapters.
- A Quiet Advocate: says US mainstream socialism discourse is a psy-op by Reaganite libertarian fake right and the left: one says healthcare/college = Soviet Union 2.0; the other says open borders/DEI are inherently socialist.
- BCguy: criticizes Western socialist health systems; Canadian healthcare is poor, increasingly staffed by Asians, good only for healthy freeloaders; Canadians with money go to the US; why would conservatives want this?
- K R Bolton: adds Spengler’s “Prussian socialism” as duty within organic state; Spengler saw Marxism and capitalism as flip sides; guild socialism; Catholic social doctrine (Rerum Novarum); Austrian and Brazilian Vargas corporatism; French “planism” and Henri de Man’s revised socialism; guilds broken by liberalism; Marxian socialism is a development of liberalism, not its antithesis; Solzhenitsyn made similar point; early Labor parties supported White Australia/white South Africa; Afrikaner nationalists synthesized socialism with folk nationalism; Marx condemned “reactionary socialism” for unifying classes.
- Cleary asks for a link to Henri de Man; Bolton provides an archive.org link to The Psychology of Socialism.
- Vainovalkeat: asks if William Morris is the Pre-Raphaelite; Cleary confirms.
- Red Dawn: posts a poem, “The Song of the Iron Loom,” about workers and ownership.
- Julius Strange: says the proposed system closely resembled Nordic countries during the Cold War—racially conscious social democracy.
3. Collin Cleary, “What Socialism Is (and Isn’t),” Part 2
Thesis: socialism is not progressivism. Cleary argues that both right and left wrongly equate socialism with progressivism. The Right uses “socialism” as a catch-all for anything left-wing; the far Left calls its whole wish list “socialism” (e.g., DSA combines universal healthcare with “queer liberation” and abolishing ICE—incoherent, since open borders and a welfare state conflict). This confusion arose from a historical alliance between socialism and progressivism.
Historical argument. Following Jean-Claude Michéa and Alain de Benoist, Cleary says “socialism” appeared around 1830 and was originally neither Left nor Right. In the French Revolution, “Left” meant liberals: pro-individual rights, pro-property, anti-monarchy/church, pro-“progress,” anti-tradition. Socialism arose as a response to both the old aristocratic Right and the liberal bourgeois Left. Early socialists opposed modernity, exploitation, destruction of traditional structures, and atomization; they did not despise the past. For much of the 19th century, socialism and the Left/liberalism were separate camps. After the Dreyfus Affair, socialism allied with progressivism against the nationalist-clerical Right. From then on, socialism adopted the progressive “metaphysics of limitlessness”: growth, productivity, change for its own sake, and denigration of tradition.
Consequences. This alliance made socialism “capitalism by other means.” Soviet Marxism-Leninism became state capitalism: growth and production over workers’ control, wage slavery, bureaucratic elite, terror. Heidegger’s claim that capitalism and communism are “metaphysically identical” is invoked. Marxism wanted to liberate labor but not liberate people from labor; its classless society is “a bourgeoisie that includes everyone.” Soviet central planning failed because without a free market there is no price mechanism and no economic calculation (Mises), producing shortages and unwanted goods.
Modern Left. After communism fell, the Left conceded capitalism as the only system and shifted from workers to “marginalized groups”—blacks, women, homosexuals, transgenders, migrants—integrating them into capitalism rather than challenging it. Today’s Left is an affluent, university-educated, urban elite that attacks moral standards, hierarchy, family, community, religion, and unchosen bonds. It acts as the agent of global capitalism: capitalism needs atomized individuals and a homogenized global market; the Left provides the moral veneer (“diversity,” “liberation”) for homogenization and cheap labor. “Woke” capital is not a threat to capitalism; Leftists are now the useful idiots of global capital. Most self-described socialists are really progressives; “real socialism” has been forgotten by both supporters and opponents.
Beyond Left and Right. Cleary uses a Hegelian dialectic: mainstream “conservatism” and “Leftism” appear opposed but share an underlying commitment to liberalism and capitalism. The third position is “conservative socialism,” which affirms limits, tradition, nature, difference, hierarchy, and the common good, while rejecting progress-worship and growth. He says this is close to fascism and National Socialism, with key differences—e.g., Heidegger thought Nazism was complicit in technological modernity—but Nazism got one indispensable thing right: ethnic and cultural homogeneity. Hence conservative socialism is for the future and for white ethnostates, not the present.
He asks whether Left/Right categories remain useful. Both “Right-wing populism” and “Left-wing populism” are anti-capitalist in tendency; Tucker Carlson criticizes capitalism, GDP growth, private equity, and wealth inequality, and has friendly relations with Ana Kasparian and Cenk Uygur, who show signs of alienating from the familiar Left. A new anti-capitalist, anti-liberal movement is being born. He says he uses “conservative” provisionally: the position is not truly conservative but revolutionary. “Fascism” would be a perfect term, but no one knows what it means; today “fascist” means anyone a Leftist dislikes, and fake conservatives oppose it as “undemocratic.”
Overall logical arc
- Define socialism by common good + anti-unbridled-capitalism, not Marxism/state ownership.
- Show capitalism destroys what conservatives value, so conservatism must become anti-capitalist.
- Propose a corporatist, protectionist, social-minimum “conservative socialism.”
- Argue it requires racial homogeneity/ethnostate because trust and common good depend on ethnic similarity.
- Refute the socialism=progressivism equation by recovering early socialism’s anti-liberal, anti-modern roots.
- Conclude that Left/Right are exhausted; both mainstream sides serve liberalism/capitalism. The needed “third position” is anti-capitalist, anti-liberal, revolutionary, close to fascism/National Socialism, and future-oriented toward white ethnostates.
The comment thread largely reinforces these themes—anti-libertarianism, anti-capitalism from a white-nationalist right, interest in non-Marxist/corporatist/guild socialist traditions, and debate over private property, equality, National Socialism, and healthcare—while adding historical references and a few critiques.